Packaging – 5 (very good)
Pigment – 4 (excellent)
Application – 5 (excellent)
Wear – 4 (very good)
Longevity – 3 (average)
Overall:
I am a big fan of the Benefit BrowZings. The packaging got a 5, which was a debate for me. I like the silver, and I live the shape and size of it. I do not like the goofy looking carnival text on the front. However that is on-brand for Benefit so maybe I just need to get over it. I ended up going with a 5 because it as a mirror in it as well as three application tools, which is super convenient and nice.
I feel it has the perfect amount of pigment. The gel is slightly shear but still buildable. The powder is a little denser and heavier in pigment. Application is easy because they gel is so creamy and light, while the powder is super soft. The application tools are the perfect size to create lines and fill in eyebrows (one is rounded tip and the other is a slanted tip)
Wear and Lognevity go hand in hand a little here. A little goes a long way, and doesn’t need reapplication (unless you swim or sweat a lot). So it lasts a long time, and is a steal compared to Goof Proof. All in all I highly recommend this product.