Packaging – 4 (very good)
Variety – 4 (very good) 10
Vibrancy – 4 (very good)
Smudge Proof – 5 (excellent)
Ease of Application – 5 (excellent)
This is my new favorite eyeliner. When you sharpen it you don’t actually loose any of the eyeliner (just the casing around it) which is great! It comes in 10 colors as well. The vibrancy of each color is very good, but for the darker blues and purples it’s amazing! I love it because the colors of those darker tones look black-brown at first and then when you get closer you see the purple or blue. It also brings out the color of your eyes without making you looks crazy. It goes on really smooth and easily but my favorite thing about this product is that it is super smudge proof. I love that! I slept with it on and it was 75% perfect in the morning! It’s a great eyeliner for sure!